Quick answer: Monarch Money is the app most Mint refugees switched to, and it earned that — polished design, family sharing, and a large, active community. It's also built around live bank connections and costs $14.99/mo (or $99.99/yr). SpendGuard never asks for your bank login — you import a CSV instead — and is built specifically around FIRE metrics (savings rate, FIRE number, Monte Carlo projections) rather than general money management. SpendGuard is also cheaper: $12/mo (Pro) vs Monarch's $14.99/mo, and has a real free tier.
Last updated: October 15, 2026.
The short version
When Mint shut down, Monarch absorbed a huge share of the exodus — its signups reportedly rose about 20x in 48 hours, and it's since raised a $75M Series B at an $850M valuation. It deserves the traction: the product is genuinely well-designed, and founder Val Agostino (Mint's first product manager) built it with real aggregator experience behind it.
SpendGuard isn't trying to out-Monarch Monarch. It exists for a narrower, specific problem: people who don't want to hand their bank credentials to another aggregator to get a money dashboard, and who care more about FIRE progress — savings rate, FIRE number, portfolio — than general household budgeting.
Feature-by-feature comparison
| Monarch Money | SpendGuard | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $14.99/mo or $99.99/yr (Core); $199/yr (Plus, annual-only) | Free tier available; Pro $12/mo, Premium $24/mo |
| Free trial / free tier | 7-day trial, no free tier | Free tier forever (500 transactions/mo, 3 budget categories, Finn 5 questions/day) |
| Bank connection | Core workflow — live account aggregation, same category of tech Mint used | Never required — CSV/Excel import is the primary workflow |
| Core focus | General money management: budgets, net worth, goals, shared household view | FIRE-first: savings rate, FIRE number, and net worth are the home screen |
| FIRE-specific tools | Goal tracking, not FIRE-specific | FIRE Planner with Monte Carlo (1,000 simulations), Lean/Regular/Fat/Barista FIRE numbers |
| AI assistant | Limited AI insights | Finn — answers questions about your real transactions, budgets, and goals |
| Investment tracking | Net worth includes investment accounts | Built-in portfolio tracker (stocks, ETFs, 401k, IRA, crypto) |
| Family/shared budgeting | Strong — built for couples/households sharing one view | Not a current focus |
| Platform | iOS, Android, web | Web (mobile apps not yet built) |
| Community | Large, active, grew partly on Reddit/YouTube advocacy | New — SpendGuard is early-stage, said honestly |
(SpendGuard has fewer than 10 paying customers as of this writing. We say so on the homepage and here — an honest small number is worth more than an inflated one.)
Where Monarch genuinely wins
Three things, honestly:
Maturity and polish. Monarch has been building since 2021 with serious funding behind it. The UI is refined, the aggregation is reliable for most banks, and it handles edge cases SpendGuard, as a much newer product, hasn't hit yet.
Household/family budgeting. If you and a partner want one shared view of joint finances — shared categories, shared goals, both of you logging in — Monarch was built for exactly that. It's a genuine strength, not a minor one.
Native mobile apps. Monarch has real iOS and Android apps. SpendGuard is web-only today — if you want to check your balance from your phone the instant you think of it, that's a real gap worth knowing before you switch.
Where SpendGuard fits better
You don't want to link your bank account to get a dashboard. This is the core difference. Monarch's entire value proposition depends on connecting your accounts via aggregation — read-only, but still a standing connection to your real credentials sitting with a third party. SpendGuard's CSV import means you export from your own bank and upload the file; nothing is ever connected live.
You're optimizing for a FIRE number, not a household budget. If the question you actually ask yourself is "when can I retire" or "what's my savings rate this month," SpendGuard puts those front and center. Monarch tracks net worth and goals well, but you're using a general tool to approximate a FIRE-specific one.
You want AI that explains your spending, not just insights on a dashboard. Finn answers plain-language questions about your actual transactions — "why did groceries jump this month" gets a real, specific answer.
You want a free tier that doesn't expire. Monarch's only free option is a 7-day trial, then it's a subscription. SpendGuard's free tier has real limits (500 transactions/mo, 3 categories) but never runs out.
You're budgeting solo, not as a household. Monarch's shared-household strength is a non-feature if you're managing your own finances alone — one less reason to pay for something you won't use.
If you're coming from Monarch
You don't have to decide blind. Export your transaction history as a CSV from Monarch (or directly from your bank) and import it into SpendGuard on the free tier. If the FIRE Planner and savings-rate view tell you more about where you actually stand than Monarch's broader dashboard did, that's your answer. If you need the shared household view or native mobile apps more than you need FIRE-specific tools, Monarch's 7-day trial is still there to confirm it's the right fit.
For the specific question of why SpendGuard doesn't ask for a bank login at all, we wrote about that tradeoff separately in how to budget without linking your bank account.
SpendGuard tracks net worth, spending, and FIRE progress without a bank login — CSV import, Finn AI assistant, and a Monte Carlo FIRE Planner. Free tier available, no bank connection required to start.
Get your finances on track with SpendGuard
Track spending, plan your FIRE date, and get AI-powered advice — all in one place. Free to start.
Start for free →